Saturday, May 30, 2009

Strategic Planning at MANY

As we work this year to update the MANY strategic plan, we are asking our members and supporters to help us set the course for our future. You have three ways to become involved in this important process:


· attend one of the following discussions to ask your questions and offer your insights about advocacy, legislation, standards and trends affecting your work. Here’s the schedule so far:


Monday, June 8: Holland Land Office
Museum
, Batavia; 3-5 pm


Tuesday, June 9: Tanglewood Nature
Center
, Elmira; 1-3 pm


Wednesday, June 10: Oneida Community
Mansion House
, Oneida; 10 am – Noon


Wednesday, June 10: Shaker Heritage
Society
, Albany; 3-5 pm


Friday, June 26: Manitoga,
Garrison; 10-Noon


Thursday, July 9: Alley Pond
Environmental Center
, Douglaston (Nassau County); 1-3
pm


Friday, July 10: Long Island
Museum
, Stony Brook (Suffolk County); 10-Noon

Dates and locations are being confirmed for NYC.

AND....use this blog to tell us what your vision is for New York state's museum community


To view the current strategic plan, click here.


Photo: The Future Looks Bright by Cayusa

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Deliberating Deaccession

Posted by Senator José M. Serrano

Although I am a frequent
blogger, this is actually my first time delving into the guest-blog-stratosphere, and I am honored to do so on the MANY website. As the new Chairman of the Senate Committee on Cultural Affairs, Tourism, Parks and Recreation, I am focused on exploring ways the State Legislature can best support and promote the tremendous cultural and natural assets within the State of New York.

Of course, this is not an easy time to be a proponent of arts and culture. On the one hand, the State is facing a massive fiscal crisis with looming budget cuts across the State. On the other hand, we know that New York’s creative sector will play a vital role in our economic recovery.

Cultural institutions, such as museums, make an enormous contribution to the State economy by stimulating tourist activity, creating jobs, utilizing other local businesses and generating tax revenue. In other words, it makes good financial sense to support the arts in New York. Not to mention, the contribution that the arts make to our quality of life and the health of our society which is immeasurable. This isn’t just political rhetoric, if you take a look at my legislative grants (AKA member items) you can see how serious I am about supporting the arts. Not only did I provide funding for a variety of art organizations, but I also took the unprecedented step of allocating $250,000 to the New York State Council on the Arts (NYSCA) for grant-making purposes.

Museums throughout the state are grappling with enormous financial problems. Unfortunately, Museums are being forced to lay off staff and manage their collections, buildings and programs with fewer resources. In some instances, museums and other cultural institutions have been driven to consider deaccessioning and then sell collection items to raise needed funds. No matter how few times this has happened, I am deeply concerned about the effect this could have on the long-term health of our cultural institutions and what this means for the cultural heritage of our state.

I recently convened a
committee meeting to discuss legislation (S.4584/A.6959) related to museum “deaccessioning” that I have introduced (along with co-sponsoring Senators Hassell-Thompson, Little, Montgomery, Morahan, and Schneiderman). To help us understand the intricacies of the bill, the committee was joined by Assembly sponsors, Assembly members Brodsky and Titone. Representatives from the Museum Association of New York, Everson Museum, Hudson River Museum, and the New York State Museum were on hand to offer their perspective on the fiscal crisis facing museums and the proposed legislation. All of our guests did a phenomenal job helping us to hash out the particulars of the bill. As a result, my colleagues and I have identified several flaws in the bill and are diligently working on some necessary revisions.

The fiscal crisis may be temporary, but the long term effects of unfettered deaccessioning will be long lasting. This legislation will place some necessary limits on deaccessioning without being overly restrictive. While changes to the bill are in the works, the essential goal of the bill will remain the same---help us maintain the cultural heritage of the State of New York in a time of deep fiscal crisis.

Just as I was able to work with the museum community on the issue of deaccessioning, I look forward to working closely with all members of the museum community on future issues. Together we can ensure New York remains the premier cultural destination in the world.


Photo: Statue sunbathing in the new Greek/Roman room at the Met by ext212, flickr

Thursday, April 2, 2009

Conference Draws 250+ to Tarrytown

Opening Keynoter, Nina Simon

This year's Upstate History Alliance/Museum Association of New York conference underwent a major redo that focused plenaries and sessions on conversations. The range of topics was not only timely, but meant to attract museum professionals, board members, volunteers and students from across the wide spectrum of the field. The goal was to be a fresh, issues-oriented, and dynamic gathering of colleagues.

Did we succeed?

One participant made it a point of seeking me out to tell me that she really enjoyed the conference more than other years. "The discussion format allowed for more issues to be raised that never would have gotten out on the table," she said. Indeed, it's hard to predict where a topic might go when left to a group to manage it, but that was part of the intent...and, hopefully, the joy one gets from discovering something new or different.

Judging from the high buzz among participants in many venues, it seems that we got close. As we continue to refine and practice the conversational method, we will no doubt get better.

So, let us know your impressions of Tarrytown 2009.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Staffing Cutbacks and Hiring Freezes on Rise in NYS' Museum Community

Pre-Recession Facts

17,000+ the number of people employed in the New York State’s museums and heritage organizations

3.1% projected employment growth by the New York State Bureau of Labor Statistics for museums until 2016

$1 Billion+ the operating expenditures of New York State museums, the majority of these expenses are returned to the state’s economy in the form of wages, purchases, and sales taxes.


The Labor Situation Now

In polling conducted by MANY of its membership in January and March 2009:

· institutional operating deficits are significantly on the rise (from 36% of reporting institutions in January to 53% of reporting institutions in March)
· staff cuts and/or freezes are now in effect at nearly half of reporting institutions
Staff reductions are running between 10-20% at institutions across the state. Furloughs and salary cuts are two measures some museums are using to avoid layoffs.

The vast majority of museums in New York State are small, historical societies and historic sites. Many of these institutions employ part-time professional staff, such as curators, educators and tour guides. These employees may be the first to be laid off because of their part-time status or they may be forced to leave because they cannot afford to stay in a part-time situation. Wrote one museum director, “I am very afraid that we will lose the talented recent Cooperstown graduate who is our part-time education director. She has mentioned that people who work in low skill jobs such as warehouses earn more than she does.”


The Impact

· reductions in museum programming that benefit New York State residents
· a “brain drain” of talent from the field to other fields where employment may be more stable, pays more and offers benefits

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

New York's Museums Respond to a Difficult & Changing Market: A Quarterly Report

by Joan Baldwin

A lot can happen in three months. Last fall when MANY approached its members about the plunging stock market more than a few said there was belt tightening going on, but maintained a wait and see attitude. All that seems to have changed with the New Year. To monitor changes from rough to dire, MANY has developed an Economic Health Index Survey for New York’s museums, polling 37 member organizations on such areas as visitation, government support, operating deficits and the like. Results from the survey will be reported in MANY’s enewsletter quarterly throughout 2009.

The news, based on the January 2009 survey, isn’t good. For 40-percent of the responding organizations school visitation is down, a victim no doubt of dwindling state and local budgets. In line with that 17 or 53.1 percent report that state or federal support has decreased. A quarter of the group (25.8 percent) has also cancelled programs, while 11 of them have experienced staff cuts or freezes. Twelve organizations or 38.7 percent report an increase in their operating deficit, and that same group (38.7 percent) reports a decrease in their number of employees. While 25.8 percent of respondents said they had scaled capital programs back.

After a number of articles appeared in the national press about the “death of the gala,” MANY asked specifically what responding organizations were doing in terms of their annual fund-raising events. Roughly 20 percent reported no change in plans. Either they had already held their event and emerged unscathed or they felt confident enough to go forward. A few respondents were more direct. One said, “Our primary focus is insuring all that we do is on mission. We are not cancelling events and programs, just being visibly cost-conscientious while trying to still attain the "wow" factor. It's important to remain the "shining star" in our community, especially during the rough road ahead.” Another quipped, “Galas should die a natural death. They are ineffective, time consuming ways to raise money and virtually all organizations would be better off if they morphed fundraising emphasis to ASKING MAJOR DONORS FOR MONEY FOR MISSION. I call it the "Willie Horton School of Fundraising".

The only good news the group reported was that 40.6 percent said that their general visitation had increased, while roughly a third or 10 percent reported their annual appeal contributions were up as well. And on the staff side where many respondents said the cuts will be (or have been) the most difficult, 41.4 percent reported no change in staffing.

Salary Survey Reveals Important Human Resource Information

by Joan Baldwin

Of the Museum Association's many accomplishments in 2008, one of the most important is the biannual salary survey. The most comprehensive of its type, this year its autumn arrival was dwarfed by a landmark election followed by a roller coaster of financial woe. As autumn turned to winter, many institutions were too busy maintaining the status quo, to think about new hires. Nonetheless, until 2010, MANY's salary survey remains the go-to document for anyone hiring or job hunting in New York's museum world.

Begun in 1972, the survey tracks benefits and compensation for more than 100 of the state's museums and historical organizations with organizational budgets ranging from $80,000 or less per year to those with budgets of $8 million or more. Utilized by job seekers, current employees, and organizations with job vacancies, it tracks individual positions ranging from directors to museum store managers, from curators to archivists, and exhibit designers to volunteer coordinators. Its small size means that especially at the high and low ends where there are only a few museums in a given budget category, positions must be combined to avoid revealing too much information about a given organization. In addition, in a survey this size, the addition or absence of a big-budget organization in any given year changes the results dramatically.

That said, there was good news and not so good news buried in the 97-page document, confirming some stereotypes and raising some questions. Not surprisingly, salaries are higher in New York City than upstate, but the differences are most acute at the biggest museums--those with budgets in excess of 8 million. In smaller institutions, particularly those with budgets of $800,000 or less, urban and rural salaries were much closer, something for job hunters to consider given the dramatic difference in the cost of living between upstate and New York City.

Another fact that stands out is that relatively speaking development directors--presumably the individuals with the most responsibility for fund raising after the director--do not get paid that much. Again, except in New York City's biggest museums, directors of development make on average 41 to 60 percent of the director's salary and are consistently paid less than say chief curators and heads of education. Since this is one position with a skill set transferable outside the museum world, do the state's museums and historical organizations lose development talent to other non-profits where pay is better?

Then there is the question of gender. It is common knowledge that in a field dominated by women, salaries decline. (Of the 100-plus positions in the 2008 survey, 60 percent are held by women, and nationally, regardless of profession women working full-time earn approximately 77 percent of men working full-time.) The good news is that in New York state's museums, at least in the director's position, there appears to be little difference in pay between men and women. Sadly, for the majority of other positions regardless of location (New York City versus Upstate), men make more than women, sometimes a lot more. While this is by no means true for all positions, it remains a red flag for women changing positions or entering the field for the first time.

Lastly, for those considering investing in a graduate degree, according to the salary survey, the museum field still considers them to be important. And not just the masters degree. According to the survey, the bigger its budget, the more education and experience organizations want. Of 25 museums with budgets over $2.6 million in the 2008/09 survey, 25 percent have directors with a doctorate, and all wanted 10 or more years experience for anyone with aspirations for the corner office. In the states' smaller museums--those with budgets from $260,000 to $2.6 million--more than half of the CEOs have a master's degree, and six have the doctorate or another terminal degree.

To order MANY's 2008-09 Salary and Benefits Survey, click here.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

MANY Members Weigh in About Handling Investments in the Climate


One of our institutional members recently posed the following question:

Our museum has a restricted account to be used for acquisition and conservation of the collection. This account is invested with a brokerage firm and due to the current economic crisis this account has been losing money – we are currently down 14%. Are museums riding out the storm or are they moving their funds to “safer” investments (such as cds)?

Here’s what the collective wisdom of the MANY membership had to say:

1. First of all, an investment policy is a good thing for all organizations to have. This is the document that outlines the "risk tolerance" of the board and staff to help an investment advisory firm.

For us, we have split our endowment. We have moved 1/2 of it to an active investment management firm whose goal is to minimize our exposure. We have retained the other 1/2 with a traditional and conservative banking institution. We rely on these institutions to preserve our position. The banking institution has held some of our portfolio in cash.

Mark Mortenson, President & CEO
Buffalo Museum of Science

2. If the account is only down about 14% they are doing better than most people. The middle of the storm is not the best time to be switching. It would have the effect of solidifying their losses.

The key going into this and coming out is diversification of assets. No one can really outguess the market for timing, winners and losers. They should have professional advisors help them spread their account into a variety of asset classes.

Approaching this year, many organizations moved a greater percentage of assets from equity to fixed income investments. But none of us should be giving advice from afar.

They might start by talking to the people who handle their account and get their perspective. Ask for comparisons to other similar size accounts, ask for analysis against the basic indexes.

A lot depends on size. The smaller the account the less llikely it can be shaped in any meaningful way. The larger the account, the more likely they will have meaningful options.

Michael Botwinick, Director
Hudson River Museum

3. We’re riding out the storm as taking $$ out of down investments only cements the loss. Given that restricted accounts are there for the long term, our investments are relatively conservative to begin with and we have great faith that they will regain their value.

What we’re doing on a day-to-day basis is looking at unnecessary expenditures, not replacing open positions for the immediate future, and behaving cautiously in all spending and budget projections for the next 12-18 months. I don’t know what is happening with the NYS budget but here in Pennsylvania, the public funds via the state arts and humanities councils are being trimmed on average by 5% or so for the FY2008-2009 cycle in terms of grants already announced. What will happen with the 2009-2010 grant cycle is anyone’s guess as those applications are all due in December of this year with the funding to be announced next summer.

Cara A. Sutherland, Executive Director
Everhart Museum of Natural History, Science & Art

4. In the case of our acquisition fund, we invest it in a Money Market fund and have for some years - the reason being we can have access to the funds readily. Not the case with endowment, which is invested diversely, but still taking a hit (!) right now. With endowment we are not allowed to invade the principal --so it is invested and until six months ago was doing fine.

Geoffrey Platt, Director
Boscobel Restoration, Inc.

5. Shaker Heritage Society decided to put all funds from the sale of collections into a series of CDs. These fund are restricted by state law so, we didn't feel that we could risk losing any principle.
Personally I think that if the funds are restricted by the board, (and are not derived from the sale of collections) they can invest however they want to. Their decision about how to invest the funds would depend largely on when they might need to access the funds, how large the fund is and what type of investments they hold. Obviously they would want to make a change if they hold a lot of stocks in the financial and automotive industry. Some other sectors might do well over the long run and may be worth holding onto. They will need to research the market a bit to help with their decision. I don't think it's a good idea to just go with whatever their broker says. We went to the Community Foundation in Albany and discussed our restricted funds with one of their board members and staff. It was very helpful. Maybe this museum could seek similar guidance. We ended up placing all of our funds with the Foundation because we simply don't have the resources to manage the fund ourselves. So far, we are pleased with the results.


Starlyn D’Angelo, Executive Director
Shaker Heritage Society

6. The Suffolk County Historical Society is going to stay put for the time being and keep our eye on our investments. It is certainly painful to sell when your investments have lost so much value. Our broker has told me a number of times that there has never been a period of 20 years when investments have not made money. (I think I have that right.) The point being that stock market investments are not for the short haul, but should be thought of as long-term investments. That being said, we will more than likely be going through a painful “belt-tightening” period.

Wally Broege, Director
Suffolk County Historical Society

7. We haven't sold any part of our invested endowment (a stock portfolio plus Vanguard mutual funds) because we have faith that the markets will recover in the long run, and in the short run our dividends derived therefrom are holding up pretty well even though the paper value of the investments has declined substantially. What we have done because of recent events is to spread out the "cash" (Money Market and CDs) we are saving toward construction of a new Educational Center at our Mabee Farm to maximize FDIC insurance protection, taking advantage of the new limit of $250,000 in any one bank.

Edward Reilly, President
Schenectady County Historical Society

8. We have an endowment fund (with several restricted smaller funds) that is down by about 30% from its high in January this year. We pay an investment management firm to manage our endowment fund. The managers are generally putting a bit more into "safer" investments like govt. bonds, and increasing the cash holdings within the endowment fund. Otherwise, they manage the fund pretty much the same. [Now's the time to buy high yielding stocks at bargain prices.] The museum takes 5% of a rolling 12 quarter average of our endowment each year for use as operating dollars in our budget. Since the worst investment quarter was only recently, we still have a pretty healthy amount that we can budget from our endowment for 2009, more than we did for 2008.

The annual gift appeal from the membership and local foundation grants are a different story altogether! Those will all be down considerably in 2009's budget.

Amy Wilson, Director
Chemung County Historical Society

Photo: Tang Teaching Museum, Skidmore College